2014 Victory Judge Review

Variation on a theme

Share this Article

2014 Victory Judge

Editor Score: 86.75%
Engine 18/20
Suspension/Handling 12.5/15
Transmission/Clutch 8.75/10
Brakes 8.25/10
Instruments/Controls3.75/5
Ergonomics/Comfort 9.0/10
Appearance/Quality 9.0/10
Desirability 9.0/10
Value 8.5/10
Overall Score86.75/100

Victory Motorcycles, while still a relatively small manufacturer, has found a way to efficiently produce its cruiser line. All of its cruiser models utilize the same engine and the same basic chassis design, allowing the development costs to be amortized across many more units than if each bike were developed independently. While this is hardly unique among the OEMs (most break up their cruiser lines along displacement categories), what makes Victory different is that a single engine configuration is used for every bike they make. Additionally, the entire cruiser line (seven models) uses the same basic chassis.

With the same powerplant motivating all of its cruisers and the same basic chassis carrying both the rider and engine, what you’re getting with a particular Victory model is pretty much a known quantity, with only details like the rider’s triangle or the handling effects of different diameter or widths of tires being the primary factors in any qualitative differences in performance. So, after enjoying the recently released Gunner, I was intrigued by the opportunity to ride Victory’s other bobber, the Judge, to see if the Gunner’s touted improvements over the other cruiser models were fact or just marketing hype.

The Judge was an ideal mount for getting around in the Daytona Beach traffic, but it really shone when it got out on the open road.

The Judge was an ideal mount for getting around in the Daytona Beach traffic, but it really shone when it got out on the open road.

Introduced at the beginning of 2012 as an early release 2013 model, the Judge has gone through some small but noticeable changes for 2014. While some may say the changes merely homogenized the qualities that made the original Judge unique, the folks at Victory say that sales did not reflect the positive reviews by the moto-press. By replacing the Judge’s drag-style handlebar with a more traditional, slightly pulled back one, the Judge has increased its appeal to the average cruiser rider – at the loss of a little familiar differentiation.

2013 Victory Judge Review

In addition to the handlebar changes, the bottom of the rider triangle was also altered by moving the pegs four inches forward. Where last year’s pegs located the rider’s feet just behind the engine’s crankshaft, this year’s has them, as with almost all other Victory cruisers, slightly forward of the crank, giving a more expansive leg position. The most obvious visual change is the swapping of the rounded, number-plate-reminiscent side panels with ones that more closely follow Victory’s usual lines.

The pegs got moved 4 inches forward for 2014 while the engine is the same Freedom 106 as on the entire Victory cruiser line.

The pegs got moved 4 inches forward for 2014 while the engine is the same Freedom 106 as on the entire Victory cruiser line.

Since the same Freedom 106 engine is used in all Victorys, we already had a fairly good idea of how the Judge’s engine performs with this chassis. The easy-to-modulate clutch and ample bottom end make the stop-light shuffle a breeze. Out on the open road, power is always on tap. The response to the rider’s throttle inputs delivers well-metered results from the engine’s iconic black, 50-degree V-Twin and it’s claimed 110 ft-lb of torque. Vibration is minimal at most engine speeds. Our bike had one alteration from stock that should be noted: The 101 x 108mm cylinders and their four-valve heads exhaled through a pair of blacked-out Stage One Straights exhaust system.

With the grips of the 2014 model being 3.75 inches closer to the rider, the Judge is more comfortable at a variety of speeds, while the previous iteration’s forward reach to the drag-style bar favored all-out acceleration.

With the grips of the 2014 model being 3.75 inches closer to the rider, the Judge is more comfortable at a variety of speeds, while the previous iteration’s forward reach to the drag-style bar favored all-out acceleration.

The result of this modification is a throaty but not overly loud exhaust note and the type of well-sorted power delivery you’d expect from a factory performance upgrade. If you’re curious as to how the power delivery compared to its Gunner sibling, the exhaust brings the Judge’s performance close, but not quite to the level of the stock Gunner. This is most likely due to the fact that the Judge’s 16-inch aluminum wheels are a heavier five-spoke design, and the additional rotating mass blunts the performance a bit. The six-speed transmission has the typical Victory clunk of recent years, not the intriguing new slickness I noted on the Gunner.

The riding position is almost the same as the Gunner’s, with decent ground clearance allowing a reasonable level of corner-riding fun before the pegs start grinding. The upper body is in a good position to combat what wind blast isn’t mitigated by the rider’s position down in the bike (thanks to the 25.9-in. seat height).

When the time comes to slow down, the single 300mm floating disc with its four-piston caliper does a good job, but I can’t help but think that I’d prefer the additional stopping power offered by an additional disc. That said, the 64.8 inch wheelbase of the bike allows for a judicious use of the 300mm rear disc and its two-piston caliper for quick stops.

The single front disc was adequate for hauling the Judge down from speed. All It took was a healthy squeeze of the lever.

The single front disc was adequate for hauling the Judge down from speed. All It took was a healthy squeeze of the lever.

Since the Judge uses the same chassis and suspension, the handling is what you’d expect from a Victory cruiser. Steering inputs receive a quick response. The suspenders are on the firm side for cruisers but only exhibit some harshness over square-edged bumps. Those who want a little more ground clearance can opt for the one-inch taller accessory shock.

The seat shape was comfortable and kept the reach to the ground to just 25.9 inches. Unfortunately, this seat absorbed water in a rain storm and got my butt wet while riding the next morning.

The seat shape was comfortable and kept the reach to the ground to just 25.9 inches. Unfortunately, this seat absorbed water in a rain storm and got my butt wet while riding the next morning.

The Judge’s fit and finish is on par with Victory’s reputation. The Gloss Havasu Red has a pearlescence that must be seen to be appreciated. The depth of the sparkle changes radically from flat light on a cloudy day to sharp highlights on a sunny one. (The other color option is glossy black.) The rear fender has the same abbreviated length as the Gunner, though the front fender is a little larger while still appearing minimalist. As with the Gunner, this is the best that a OEM can do to create a bobber. If desired, the rest of the bobbing will have to be done by the buyer.

All-in-all, the 2014 Victory Judge retains most of what we liked about it last year while broadening the bike’s appeal with the new riding position. In the case of the Judge, $13,999 buys a sporty, good-looking premium cruiser with no frills and weighs in as a good bang for the buck.

The five spoke wheels and the brawny Dunlop K491 tires add to the muscle bound stance of the Judge.

The five spoke wheels and the brawny Dunlop K491 tires add to the muscle bound stance of the Judge.

+ Highs

  • Solid performance
  • Improved riding position
  • Reasonably priced premium cruiser
- Sighs

  • Seat retained water after rain
  • Single front disc
  • Loss of some uniqueness compared to previous model

Free Insurance Quote

Enter your ZIP code below to get a free insurance quote.

Victory Dealer Price Quote

Get price quotes for Victory from local motorcycle dealers.

Victory Communities

Get Motorcycle.com in your Inbox
  • Tom Dinchuk

    Let’s get real here!….The bike is heavy, with foot pegs moved even farther forward. both the front and rear tires are too wide. The suspension is poor at best and you don’t have double discs up front. I’m wondering why my 2002 Super Glide Sport is 12 years old
    and a much better ride than this Polaris Junkwagon.

    • sgray44444

      I’m not a Harley fan, but you have a point, Tom. With the shared platform, you would think they could do better for the money. Dual discs should be mandatory on a heavy bike like this.
      The things they did made it look a little better, but now it’s just bland as can be.

  • Kenneth

    Tom Dinchuk: I owned a new 2005 Super Glide, so I know what a “junkwagon” is (oil leak that the dealer repeatedly “fixed,” + unfixable high-frequency engine vibration). I sold that dog after 3 months, and would gladly give Polaris a try.

    • Tom Dinchuk

      You didn’t own a Super Glide Sport. It’s a totally different bike. Sounds like you got a lemon.

  • Old MOron

    Hey Evans, as the FNG you keep drawing the cruiser assignments, eh?
    I wonder when Commander Duke is going to let you ride something that stops and turns.
    [/gratuitous yet too-easy-to-resist cruiser and FNG joke]

    • Evans Brasfield

      Later today, you’ll get to read about the fun I was having yesterday.

      Oh, and I was hired to be the cruiser guy, which is a good gig, IMHO. :-P

  • Morty

    I loved the Judge when it first came out , I actually rode one 3 times on the same day when the demo truck was at Hinshaw’s in Auburn WA . It was the only cruiser that caught my fancy (I’m a die hard ST guy) . It was fast , manuevarable and the main plus was you didn’t ride on it seated in thaty typical cruiser foot forward position that doesn’t allow you to use your legs to help absorb sudden bumps , The seating position was almost identical to my old 99 Kawasaki Concours , well now that they revamp (read followed the herd) in cruiser styling it definitely .what a let down .

  • http://www.themotorcycleobsession.com/ Chris Cope

    I test rode a Judge this weekend and I think you’re being too kind about the brakes. When I first grabbed the front brake I thought it wasn’t there!

  • bigjames

    Meh! Looks like a clone of a Japanese Clone…once removed…motor has always looked a little plastic to me. Amazing when you think they also came up with the new Indian engine. I give them a do over…soon.