The Return of Two Strokes?
Get ready for a serious comeback of two-strokes in the near future with engines that can compete with four-strokes head-to-head in emission cleanliness, fuel economy, and ride-ability, all the while retaining power, size, and weight advantages over four-strokes. Off-road and motorcross riders have long enjoyed the benefits of two-strokes, which have evolved into highly reliable motors.
For you (American) street riders out there, two-strokes have been a thing of the past, banned in the U.S. for their unclean emissions since 1985 (100cc and over). Just when two-stroke fans had given up and bought old, clapped-out two-stroke street bikes, Honda is now poised to bring them back.
Dusk in the desert. Big Red has designed and built a race-winning two-stroke prototype that has emissions comparable to a four-stroke. Named the EXP-2, this bike has demonstrated the possibility of a rebirth of the two-stroke engine as an environmentally friendly machine.World sales figures for two- and four-strokes. Two-strokes have several advantages over their four-stroke counterparts: For a given engine displacement, a two-stroke is lighter, smaller, produces more power, and has fewer moving parts. This makes it less expensive to manufacture -- especially since the motors can be fitted to smaller, lighter chassis -- more reliable, and easier to maintain than a four-stroke.
Two-strokes have their disadvantages as well -- they produce more harmful carbon monoxide and hydrocarbon emissions than four-strokes, putting them outside the realm of on-road emissions laws in America, and outside future requirements of other countries. In many developing countries with less restrictive or non-existent emissions laws, two-strokes are the motor of choice for the majority of motorcycles. In fact, they are so widely used that Honda estimates two- and four-stroke engines are built in equal quantities worldwide. The applications for current two-strokes are vast, but a future of environmentally friendly emission laws puts current two-stroke technology in jeopardy.
The curved yellow valve rotates on a pivot to open and close the exhaust port; it is shown in the closed position. The causes of high emissions of two-stroke engines are relatively simple, and are attributable to the basic way a two-stroke operates. There are two main factors which cause poor emissions: Incomplete combustion of fuel at low engine RPM, and expulsion of unburnt fuel out with the exhaust at high engine RPM, with both problems compounded by the fact that oil is injected into the motor to lubricate the crankshaft, and is then burnt off in combustion.
The EXP-2 was designed to solve the first of these problems which occurs because, during the two-stroke cycle, fuel enters the cylinder through the intake port in the side of the cylinder, and pushes spent gases out of the exhaust port in the opposite cylinder wall at the same time.
In doing this, the fuel and exhaust mix somewhat, causing some exhaust to remain in the cylinder with the incoming fuel.
When the spark plug fires and ignites the fuel mixture, some of the fuel is isolated from the resulting flame by the exhaust still in the cylinder, and does not burn.
"What Honda has done is to develop a way to ignite all the fuel in the cylinder by using the properties of auto-ignition, and has termed this process Activated Radical Combustion."What Honda has done is to develop a way to ignite all the fuel in the cylinder by using the properties of auto-ignition, and has termed this process Activated Radical Combustion. This title is derived from the way fuel actually ignites. When the fuel is brought to the right pressure and temperature, the molecules break down into what are known as active radical molecules.
These are highly unstable chemical compounds which are an intermediate step in the actual combustion reaction. When hot exhaust gas remains in the cylinder, it contains a small percentage of active radical molecules; when these are combined with the incoming fuel charge, the resulting mixture begins to auto-ignite at lower temperature that a pure gasoline/airmixture.
What we currently associate with auto-ignition is engine knock, a phenomenon that occurs when the fuel ignites before the spark plug fires, while the piston is still on the up-stroke. In the EXP-2, Honda has developed an exhaust port valve which raises and lowers the top of the exhaust port, thereby decreasing and increasing the fuel mixture pressure in the cylinder as needed. This valve is similar in shape to a power valve, but larger, and is shown in detail in these two cut-away diagrams. By setting the valve position based on engine RPM and throttle position, the pressure required for auto-ignition can be achieved at exactly the right timing, causing all of the fuel in the cylinder to burn completely. This process has the added benefit of increasing low RPM power and throttle response, a current problem area with two-strokes.
Honda EXP-2 combustion process1. Fresh fuel (white) enters the combustion chamber, pushing the exhaust (grey) out the open exhaust valve on the opposite side of the cylinder. 2. The incoming fuel mixes with the exhaust, and some pockets of fuel are isolated within the exhaust. The exhaust valve closes and the compression of the mixture is increased as the piston travels upward. 3. The fuel/exhaust mixture is compressed and auto-ignites as the piston reaches the top of its stroke. This burns all of the fuel, and reduces the emission of unburnt hydrocarbons into the environment.
At small throttle openings, a conventional two-stroke will start a repeating pattern of misfiring, which allows a large amount of unburnt gas and oil to be expelled directly into the atmosphere. At these low engine speeds, the amount of fuel entering the combustion chamber is small compared to the amount of exhaust remaining, which creates a mixture that is not ignited by the spark, and is expelled directly into the exhaust system. Each time this misfire occurs, the amount of fuel remaining in the cylinder increases, until it is great enough to be ignited by the spark.
"When it is ignited, the cylinder is again filled with exhaust and the cycle repeats itself."
By measuring cylinder pressure over time, this cycle can be seen as a pattern of regular large increases in pressure. The increases in pressure mark the points where the mixture burns; between these pressure peaks is the area where all of the fuel and oil are going out the pipe without burning, which is a major source of emissions and exhaust system contamination. As can be seen from the graph below, this cycle occurs at low and medium loads during conventional two-stroke combustion.
The vertical peaks are firing cycles, and the area between peaks are misfires. By igniting the entire mixture without the use of a spark, the EXP-2 is able to burn all of the fuel and oil in the cylinder in every cycle, eliminating the misfiring cycle described above. By eliminating misfiring, the motor actually burns much more of the fuel that it consumes; this reduces the amount of unburned fuel and oil released into the atmosphere, which greatly decreases hydrocarbon emissions. The graph of cylinder pressure below illustrates the resulting constant pressure, which indicates that the fuel is burning on each cycle.
As a test for this technology, Honda built a 400cc single-cylinder bike for off-road and desert endurance racing. The 400cc single design was chosen because it has a large combustion chamber and a high piston speed, making for difficult burn characteristics; if the EXP-2 system works for this configuration, it will work for smaller piston engines.
Fuel injection was also used for ease of setup and fuel measurement, although the system was designed to work with carbureted systems as well. The race results were very good even though the bike was not designed to win races, but to test new technology. When the dust settled, the EXP-2 had earned 5th overall and 1st in both the under 500cc and experimental classes at the Granda-Dakar rally; 1st in the two-stroke class and 8th overall in the Nevada Rally last year, and 7th overall motorcycle at the Baja 1000.
Honda's riding team of Chuck Miller,Paul Ostbo and Greg Bringle finished 7th overall and first in class in the Baja 1000. Compared to Honda's current NXR780 four-stroke twin rally race bike, the EXP-2 has very similar performance with several advantages. While the single cylinder EXP-2 produces 54hp to the big NXR's 71, they both make 58 lb-ft of torque, but the EXP-2 is 118 pounds lighter, giving it a slightly better power-to-weight ratio.
What all this boils down to is that the EXP-2 has about the same real-world performance as the 780, but with substantially better fuel economy and lower emissions. By increasing the mileage of the bike, it can be raced carrying less fuel, which improves handling and decreases rider fatigue. The problem of unburnt fuel escaping with the exhaust has yet to be solved, but for all you two-stroke die-hards out there: stay tuned, this is the start of something we have all been waiting for.