Motorcycle Insurance: Comprehensive Collision Coverage

Painful explanation to a question no one asked

After publishing the second part of this series that discussed Property Damage and Medical Payments, the subject came up in the article’s forum thread about the agent getting you to buy the maximum of everything.

“Insurance is Vegas without showgirls,” was my reply. You pay into the premium, but you are betting on not wrecking or having a claim of any type. The funny thing is that there is a “no lose” in a sense here. If you pay and make no claim, the house wins (the underwriters in this case). If you have a claim, you win and the house loses. It makes sense doesn’t it?

When someone on the forum suggested that I recommend you to purchase the most coverage only to maximize my commission, it made me feel bad that people really don’t understand this insurance stuff better. (The following statement does not imply every insurance professional or company endorses the following.)

Insurance agents, brokers and underwriters have a dirty little secret they prefer you not be aware of: They encourage lower limits and high deductibles. Why? Loss ratio. These big underwriters have this business down, and in the motorcycle world, the “acceptable” loss ratio for most companies is right around 70% of the written premium.

Written premium is the total amount of business I send them in a calendar year. So, if I write $100,000 annual for the largest motorcycle underwriter in the USA and I have $63,000 worth of loss payments between bodily injury and property claims, my loss ratio of 63% is squeaking by the threshold of losing them and me money for the year. If underwriters and agents sell you the higher limits, the faster you will reach the threshold.

Agents can be suspended from writing business if the loss ratio is too high and show no signs of reversal. It’s happened with a company I did business with. I actually insure my bike with them but can’t write a lick of new business until they get the chip off their shoulder and understand that I can’t fix it until I can write something that makes them money, like simple liability policies. It happens. You get used to it in this business. We agents have more at stake than you ever thought, huh? Selling comprehensive and collision coverage just makes the loss ratio move up that much faster.

Comprehensive coverage has deductibles from $0-$1000 usually. Premiums go up when you choose a lower deductible.  But there’s a limit in change, so ask the difference in price. A great example of this is a dual-sport bike. It’s usually just a few dollars of difference between a $500 and $250 deductible for a guy over 25 years of age. So, in this case, pick the low deductible.

Motorcycle Insurance: Comprehensive Collission Coverage

If you own a full-blown custom motorcycle worth $35,000 or more, then you could not only afford the financial responsibility of a $1000 deductible, but I’d encourage it. Customs are difficult to insure and the rates are usually not far off what some kid on a liter-class sportbike would pay in premium. You might as well keep that premium low.

What’s Comp coverage cover? It covers theft, fire, vandalism and acts of nature. Theft is self-explanatory. Fire insurance covers spontaneous or malicious (by anyone but you or a family member) incidents. I say that because I had a customer’s wife set his bike ablaze and they denied the claim. Don’t let your family set your bike on fire…period.

The family member rule also applies to Vandalism coverage. Spontaneous acts of nature, like a tree falling on your bike, flood and a few highly unlikely things that you can read in your policy documents. If you ever believe you have a comprehensive claim, take pictures of everything for documentation. Get police reports if possible.

Collision is easy. You wreck it and it gets fixed, less the deductible. The deductibles are the same $0-$1000, and the reasons will once again vary depending on the same reasons as I stated in the comprehensive paragraph. If you low-side or high-side your bike and it was not due to another vehicle making contact with you, then you will be responsible for your own medical treatment and the bike will be considered a collision claim.

Motorcycle Insurance: Comprehensive Collission Coverage

Is hitting sand in the road an “act of nature”? No! It’s more likely it’s because of a lazy D.O.T., but it will be counted as a collision claim. You control your bike and it’s your duty to be aware of the roadway. Again, fully documenting the incident can drastically shortcut headaches.

If you’re street rider who likes to occasionally ride at the track, ask your insurance agent, broker or underwriter if “track days” are covered. Unless it’s stated clearly in your customer documents that it’s not, if you go down at a track day you can get your bike fixed. It will not be covered if it’s a “timed and sanctioned” event. That means no AMA, WERA or CCS events with your streetbike or dual-sport enduros will be covered.

In the next installments, we’ll discuss gear, optional equipment, towing, age, types of bikes, geographic location and how your driving record will affect your rates.

Kirk Harrington is a longtime rider and avid motorcycle enthusiast, and he’s one of the nation’s only specialized motorcycle insurance agents, operating from his location north of Atlanta, Georgia.

Related Reading
Motorcycle Insurance: Casualty Liability
Motorcycle Insurance: Property or Physical Damage
Motorcycle Insurance: Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Motorcycle Insurance Buyer’s Guide
Insurance Basics

Motorcycle Insurance Providers

Motorcycle Insurance is an important decision for riders to make. Below you will find a selection of motorcycle insurance providers that can provide you with an insurance quote for your riding needs. Please take some time to review our articles, and determine the appropriate insurance protection that you require.

Progressive Insurance

Protect your motorcycle with Progressive. We offer high quality coverage at very low rates. So you can get the protection you need and still have money left over to spend on important stuff. Like pipes. Now that's Progressive. Get your free quote today.

Allstate Motorcycle Insurance

Ask how an Allstate Agent can help you get covered for when you hit the open road. Coverage options like Allstate’s exclusive Rider Protection Package offer protection for your bike's most important part: you. Plus, with Allstate we have discounts that could save you up to 50%. Call an agent for a fast, free quote today.

Dairyland Cycle Insurance

Whether you ride a Yamaha or Harley Davidson; a Suzuki or a Honda, Dairyland Cycle has the motorcycle insurance coverage options and deductibles that can meet your needs and the payment options that fit your budget.

GEICO Motorcycle Insurance

Rev up your savings with motorcycle insurance from GEICO. No matter what you own – a sport bike, cruiser, standard, touring bike, or a sweet custom ride, you can turn to us for great rates and great coverage. Enjoy the freedom of the open road knowing that the Gecko's got your back!

Rider Insurance

Ride with Rider. Rider offers motorcycle insurance for DE, IN, NJ, OH, PA, MD and WV. We're committed to providing "no hassle" service at the lowest rates possible! Call 1.800.595.6393 or go to to get an instant price quote or purchase a policy.

Leslie Kays Insurance

We combine our passion as insurance professionals and motorcyclists to provide coverage that meets your specific needs. We work longer, harder, faster and smarter for you through your adventures and misadventures 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Harley-Davidson Insurance

Protection designed exclusively for Harley riders. Harley-Davidson Insurance offers great coverage at a competitive rate along with customer and claims service from representatives who really know Harley-Davidson(r) motorcycles. Get a free quote today!
Get in your Inbox