Motorcycle Forum

Motorcycle Forum (http://www.motorcycle.com/forum/)
-   AMA Racing (http://www.motorcycle.com/forum/ama-racing/)
-   -   Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing. (http://www.motorcycle.com/forum/ama-racing/3355-carmichaels-fuel-issue-being-reviewed-ama-pro-racing.html)

killer5280 03-01-2006 06:42 AM

Re: Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing.
 
They are emulated because they are successful, financially speaking. Unfortunately, that "success" confers respectability on an inferior product, but that doesn't seem to bother the average fan who just doesn't "get" that roadracing stuff.

I can't stand NASCAR--never have been able to since I was a little kid in the 60's and 70's. The racing is kept artificially close through the use of ridiculous numbers of caution flags. The rules change on a weekly basis. It is the professional wrestling of motorsports.

As bad as the AMA is, it's still better than NASCAR. Racing in general has too many rules. It's too officious. Too often, outcomes are decided away from the racetrack. That doesn't make it more dramatic or interesting to me. It causes me to lose interest in the sport and to lose respect for the sanctioning body. If Supercross or Superbike ever get as bad as NASCAR in this respect I'll move on to something else.

longride 03-01-2006 06:52 AM

Re: Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing.
 
Every racing orginization changes rules to include many brands and keep the racing close, or at least they should. NASCAR does it better than anyone else in the world. I understand you don't like it. Lots of people don't like lots of things. I think NASCAR racing is certainly more interesting than watching the same guy win the same way on the same bike week after week, and year after year, as has happened in AMA Superbike which you seem to like alot. I think it's boring. At least the AMA bent the rules to get the Buell in the Daytona 200. Last year we saw a 3 man Pro Honda Parade with 45 privateers used as backmarkers. Maybe the AMA could use a little WWF itself.

killer5280 03-01-2006 06:58 AM

Re: Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing.
 
No thanks. Let the best man win, even if it's the same guy every week. Changing the rules all the time to make it more "fair" makes a worse product for everyone. It smacks of the kind of socialistic thinking that pervades our culture. Exalting mediocrity and penalizing excellence isn't what motorsports should be about.

dylanmo 03-01-2006 07:16 AM

Re: Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing.
 
Except that a racing league is not administering the SAT, it's meant to be selling a good race to existing, and especially potential, fans. Bureaucratic rigidity in the face of crap races, and a small and dwindling fan base, would be the socialistic sin in this case.

Tigercub 03-01-2006 08:35 AM

Re: Here's VP Fuels' response
 
Thanks for that link. I seem to recall that lead levels in ordinary leaded gasoling were on the order of 2g/L to 3g/L, which is many times higher than the limit used by AMA. What level did they measure and what was the error limit of their test?? That would tell me a lot about how good their test was. Oxygen limits would limit the use of oxygenated octane boosters like MTBE, ethanol, methanol and my favorite, pentacarbonyl. Toluene and naphthalene also work. But, I doubt anyone would bother with any of these, since race gas comes as high as 110 octane anyway. If the lead level was instituted to protect catalytic converters, what does that have to do with offroad racing? Nothing about this rule makes any sense.

killer5280 03-01-2006 09:36 AM

Re: Carmichael's Fuel Issue Being Reviewed by AMA Pro Racing.
 
I agree. I'm not advocating bureaucratic rigidity. In fact, I'm against it and that's why I think Carmichael's penalty should be overturned.

Of course rules have to be adjusted periodically, but making races artificially close by penalizing fast riders (drivers) by changing the rules weekly, a la NASCAR, and bringing out caution flags all the time, a la NASCAR, do not make for good racing. They make for dumbed down least common denominator racing. If that's the recipe for "success" then, again, no thanks.



All times are GMT -7. The time now is 02:55 AM.